Readers, I am sad to say that due to technical issues, I can't get my interview with Dan Johnson and Josh Holley and their new publishing company Golden Kid Comics to transfer properly to this blog.
However, you can read this week's Family Comic Friday in it's entirety over at FCF's sister site, Outrightgeekery.com.
My apologies for this. But it happens in the blogsphere from time to time...
A book is like the TARDIS. Open it up and it's bigger on the inside. One part reading journal, one part educational tool for pop culture newbies and parents of young geeks. This blog is your portal into the world of movies, TV, superheroes, and of course books!
Showing posts with label Family Comic Friday. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Family Comic Friday. Show all posts
Friday, June 29, 2018
Friday, December 15, 2017
Droids and Ewoks (Family Comic Friday)
With The Last Jedi debuting in theaters this weekend, I thought it would be ideal to cover something Star Wars for this week’s Family Comic Friday. While many Star Wars comics are able to be enjoyed by readers of all ages, there was only two series that I felt that really deserved my attention today. Ladies and Gentlemen, as well as kids of all-ages, I present to you Droids and Ewoks!
Both series were published beginning in 1985 by Marvel Comics. Droids and Ewoks were released as tie-ins to the ABC animated series of the same name under the Star Comics imprint. Both series were published bi-monthly. Unfortunately, neither series, just like their animated predecessors, lasted very long.Droids- written by Dave Manak. Art by John Romita Sr, Mary Wilshire, & Ernie Colon
This comic starred C-3PO and R2-D2. Billed as a prequel to A New Hope, the Droids drift around the galaxy looking for new masters. Every issue had the duo meeting new owners, getting into some sort of trouble, and then saving the day. Space Pirates, corrupt government officials, and dreadful alien smugglers were the usual assortment of baddies.
Like the cartoon it was based on, Droids did not run as long as Ewoks did. With only eight issues published, Droids is one of the hardest Star Wars comics to find. The first three issues were illustrated by Spider-Man legend John Romita Sr. The final trio of issues featured the adventures of Episode IV as told in Threepio’s point of view. They are the most sought after of the Star Comics releases.
Ewoks- Written by Dave Manak. Art by Warren Kremer
The Ewoks comic book was an odd duck just like the cartoon series it was based on. The cartoon ran for two seasons. The first season was considered to be a lot like the Ewoks live-action TV films as that there was a much more serious tone. Issues 1-4 of Ewoks featured some really fierce looking monsters and baddies that often got in the way of Wicket trying to prove that he’s ready to come of age in the tribe.
By issues 7, the second season of Ewoks had begun to debut on TV. ABC television wanted a more kid friendly look and feel to the show. As in the comic book as well as the cartoon, the monsters started to look less scary, the color palette was less serene, and some of the plots were just plain silly. Another thing that hurt the Ewoks comic was that the show’s main villains, the Duloks, a fierce rival species that looked a lot like the Grinch, were only featured in two issues. They were pretty good foils to the Ewoks but grossly underused in the comics.
The series was written by Archie Comics scribe Dave Manak. You could tell that Archie and the gang were a big influence as Wicket and fellow Ewok, Teebo, would have silly competitions for the affections of Chief Chirpa’s daughter Princess Kneesaa.
All 14 issues were illustrated by Warren Kremer, formally of Harvey Comics. Marvel in it’s attempt to rival Harvey with it’s Star Comics imprint, had lured away several big names from the rival publisher .You can really see Kremer’s style was deeply impacted by drawing Harvey Comics for so many years especially in Ewoks #9. There the children of the Undersea Kingdom look a lot like Casper the Friendly Ghost if he was a mer-creature.
A Galaxy Spanning Crossover
Fans of both Droids and Ewoks never got to see their favorite animated characters crossover on Saturday Morning TV. But in October to November, 1986, those fans got their wish in print form. In Droids #4 and Ewoks #10, C-3PO and R2-D2 made an unexpected visit to Endor.The droids were hired as nannies for an royal alien tot named the Star Child. One of the Star Child’s relatives wants the kid out of the way and jettisons the lad along with Threepio and Artoo into space and then tries to vaporize them. Instead, the escape pod hits a wormhole and are sent to Endor where they crash land.
Artoo thinks he can get the escape vessel mobile again. But it will take some time. That’s a good thing, because those evil Duloks just kidnapped the Star Child.
A Legacy Remembered
There were a number of reasons that Droids and Ewoks got the boot from TV and comics so quickly. It’s hard to believe but by 1986, Star Wars had started to run its course. With no new theatrical movies being produced, kids were interested in other things like Thundercats and Transformers. The action figure line was virtually non-existent and the toys based on these two properties were exceptionally hard to find. The main Star Wars comic was lagging in sales and Marvel had no interest in renewing the license when it came due in 1987. Ultimately, by the summer of 1988, there were no more Star Wars comics of any kind being released.For several years, there was nothing new Star Wars until in 1991 when an author by the name of Timothy Zahn wrote a little book called Heir to the Empire. Almost immediately interest in Star Wars sky-rocketed again and Dark Horse quickly snagged up the rights to the Star Wars franchise. They would published hundreds of comics based on the George Lucas for over 20 years until 2014 when Disney bought Lucasfilm and the license when back to Marvel.
Near the tale end of Dark Horse’s run on Star Wars, they began issuing collections of Marvel’s run of Star Wars comics. In 2012, they released the Star Wars Omnibus: Droids and Ewoks. This massive volume has over 500 pages and collects all 22 issues plus a bonus coloring book story set during Return of the Jedi.
Last year Marvel reissued all of the Star Comics titles under its Star Wars Legends line of reprinted comics. That volume retails for $75. However, Amazon still has a couple of dozen of the Dark Horse Omnibuses for only $15. So if you are looking to read the entire run of both series without shelling out some big bucks, this is the way to go.
Fun for Star Wars fans of all-ages. Neither of the series were really canon. But in the mid-80s, both Droids and Ewoks were the cartoon and comic fixes we were looking for.
This article was published concurrently at outrightgeekery.com.
Friday, December 8, 2017
Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur, Volume 1: BFF (Family Comic Friday)
Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur, Volume 1: BFF
Writer: Amy Reeder
Artist: Natacha Bustos
Publisher: Marvel
Thumbing through a recent issue of something, (I don't remember what), I saw an advertisement for the collected first volume of Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur. This series hadn't really been on my radar, but I was open to getting my hands on a copy if it ever turned up and my local library. What caught my eye on this particular day wasn't the artwork nor the concept but a blurb posted by another reviewer.
Citing a website called Black Nerd Problems, the blurb said that Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur was a 'fantastic read for all ages.' Since I do this weekly post where I examine family friendly comics, I was interested to know if this series really was appropriate for all ages or not. Thus, I hunted down a copy of volume one and gave it a read to see for myself what this series was all about
So let's examine all the evidence and decide if this was the correct assessment for this series.
How Does It Rate?
The cover of issue #1 rates the book for teens. According to Marvel's rating system a teen book is considered 'appropriate for most readers, but parents are advised that they might want to read before or with younger children.'
The days of a governing body determining the age appropriateness of comics is long gone.The ratings for comics are now done in house by each publisher. DC rates their own books as does Marvel. So already, Moon Girl's parent company does not consider this book to be suitable for all. While I felt that the overall of story was great for kids- a young girl befriends a dinosaur- some situations could be considered tense for younger children.
What's in the Book?
This series continues the story of Devil Dinosaur. The fiery red T-Rex like dinosaur was the creation of the great Jack Kirby and first debuted in Devil Dinosaur #1 from 1978. Devil was accompanied by a young ape-like child named Moon Boy. Together, the pair fought off extraterrestrials, other rampaging thunder lizards, and even modern day menaces like Godzilla. But the duo's prime enemies were a tribe of fierce cavemen called the Killer-Folk.
It's during a battle with the Killer-Folk, that Devil Dinosaur is sucked through a time vortex into the modern day along with a sacred rock with mystical powers called the Nightstone.
In 2016 New York City, 9-year old Lunella Lafayette is a brilliant child who is unappreciated by her teachers, peers, and parents. Lunella knows that she has the Inhuman gene and is frantically trying to cure herself before a terrigen mist cloud transforms her into something, er well, Inhuman.
When Lunella discovers the Nightstone, she sees it for what it really is, a Kree Omni-Wave Projector. However, Devil Dinosaur is fiercely protective of it and basically follows Lunella around like the world's largest red puppy. But the Killer-Folk also emerged from the time portal and they have their eyes on the Nightstone as well. As Lunella's neighborhood is terrorized by the Killer-Folk, it's up to the Devil Dinosaur and Moon Girl to restore peace to the Big Apple!
Scary Bad Guys & Bratty Children
I'm really glad that I had a collection of the first six issues of Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur. Because in that first issue, Lunella is a brat with a capital B. She was quite off-putting. If I only had that issue to base my opinion off of, I wouldn't come around for seconds.
However, as Lunella learns to become the hero Moon Girl, her personality becomes more favorable. So there's a real lesson in humility and caring for others that underlines this first story arc. In fact, I recommend that you don't read the series as individual issues as there's real character development to be explored when read as a collection.
If being a brat was cause for a book to not be considered all-ages then there wouldn't be any all-age comics at all. But one thing that I felt does mark this book as not being appropriate for readers of all ages are the villains!
The Killer-Folk start off kinda comical. Natacha Bustos' art makes them look like tiny Saquatches. But as the Nightstone evolves the cave creatures, they become more intelligent and more deadly. There's several scenes where the Killer-Folk threat to kill innocent New Yorkers and a couple of intense scenes in which people are seriously injured. Also, at one point, Lunella's school is targeted and if not for Devil Dinosaur, her classmates would have perished at the hands of the Killer-Folk. Thought Bustos' art style is more age friendly in eye appeal, the dangers presented in this book are quite grown-up.
Finding Balance
It's series such as this book as to why I write my Family Comic Friday posts. If the average parent or guardian took the praise on the front cover at face value, they might have bought this book for a younger child who might not be ready for such intense scenes. I would be okay with telling a parent of a 10 year old to let them read this book. On the flip side, I would also have to provide a strong word of caution to the caretaker of a 5-7 year old reader.
Another thing that makes this book NOT all-ages is the techno-jargon. Lunella is one smart kid and she's a lot like Young Sheldon. She might know how to use enriched uranium but she shouldn't be allow to buy enriched uranium. (Maybe when she's 10...)
Having technical terms and advanced concepts isn't a bad thing in kids books. But if you want the young comic reader to fully enjoy the book, having an adult help with big words and complex thinking isn't a bad idea. Anytime you can get a parent and child reading together, it's a good thing and this is a series that really needs a reading partner if read by a child ages 9 or younger.
Where to Now?
Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur are still going strong as a monthly series by Marvel Comics. Original series writer Amy Reeder has moved on, though Natacha Bustos currently remains as head artist. Having not read past issue #6, I can't rate those issues. But this first volume was a pleasant burst of old school characters with new dynamic roles. In an era where Marvel's comics have become almost an afterthought to the live action films that they were based upon, this series gives me hope that the House of Ideas has yet to run out of them.
Hopefully that means that this new dynamic duo is here to stay. So if Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur is just a little too old for the young comic collector in your life- don't worry! They'll grow into it!
Worth Consuming!
Rating: 8 out of 10 stars.
Writer: Amy Reeder
Artist: Natacha Bustos
Publisher: Marvel
Thumbing through a recent issue of something, (I don't remember what), I saw an advertisement for the collected first volume of Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur. This series hadn't really been on my radar, but I was open to getting my hands on a copy if it ever turned up and my local library. What caught my eye on this particular day wasn't the artwork nor the concept but a blurb posted by another reviewer.
Citing a website called Black Nerd Problems, the blurb said that Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur was a 'fantastic read for all ages.' Since I do this weekly post where I examine family friendly comics, I was interested to know if this series really was appropriate for all ages or not. Thus, I hunted down a copy of volume one and gave it a read to see for myself what this series was all about
So let's examine all the evidence and decide if this was the correct assessment for this series.
How Does It Rate?
The cover of issue #1 rates the book for teens. According to Marvel's rating system a teen book is considered 'appropriate for most readers, but parents are advised that they might want to read before or with younger children.'
The days of a governing body determining the age appropriateness of comics is long gone.The ratings for comics are now done in house by each publisher. DC rates their own books as does Marvel. So already, Moon Girl's parent company does not consider this book to be suitable for all. While I felt that the overall of story was great for kids- a young girl befriends a dinosaur- some situations could be considered tense for younger children.
What's in the Book?
This series continues the story of Devil Dinosaur. The fiery red T-Rex like dinosaur was the creation of the great Jack Kirby and first debuted in Devil Dinosaur #1 from 1978. Devil was accompanied by a young ape-like child named Moon Boy. Together, the pair fought off extraterrestrials, other rampaging thunder lizards, and even modern day menaces like Godzilla. But the duo's prime enemies were a tribe of fierce cavemen called the Killer-Folk.
It's during a battle with the Killer-Folk, that Devil Dinosaur is sucked through a time vortex into the modern day along with a sacred rock with mystical powers called the Nightstone.
In 2016 New York City, 9-year old Lunella Lafayette is a brilliant child who is unappreciated by her teachers, peers, and parents. Lunella knows that she has the Inhuman gene and is frantically trying to cure herself before a terrigen mist cloud transforms her into something, er well, Inhuman.
When Lunella discovers the Nightstone, she sees it for what it really is, a Kree Omni-Wave Projector. However, Devil Dinosaur is fiercely protective of it and basically follows Lunella around like the world's largest red puppy. But the Killer-Folk also emerged from the time portal and they have their eyes on the Nightstone as well. As Lunella's neighborhood is terrorized by the Killer-Folk, it's up to the Devil Dinosaur and Moon Girl to restore peace to the Big Apple!
Scary Bad Guys & Bratty Children
I'm really glad that I had a collection of the first six issues of Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur. Because in that first issue, Lunella is a brat with a capital B. She was quite off-putting. If I only had that issue to base my opinion off of, I wouldn't come around for seconds.
However, as Lunella learns to become the hero Moon Girl, her personality becomes more favorable. So there's a real lesson in humility and caring for others that underlines this first story arc. In fact, I recommend that you don't read the series as individual issues as there's real character development to be explored when read as a collection.
If being a brat was cause for a book to not be considered all-ages then there wouldn't be any all-age comics at all. But one thing that I felt does mark this book as not being appropriate for readers of all ages are the villains!
The Killer-Folk start off kinda comical. Natacha Bustos' art makes them look like tiny Saquatches. But as the Nightstone evolves the cave creatures, they become more intelligent and more deadly. There's several scenes where the Killer-Folk threat to kill innocent New Yorkers and a couple of intense scenes in which people are seriously injured. Also, at one point, Lunella's school is targeted and if not for Devil Dinosaur, her classmates would have perished at the hands of the Killer-Folk. Thought Bustos' art style is more age friendly in eye appeal, the dangers presented in this book are quite grown-up.
Finding Balance
It's series such as this book as to why I write my Family Comic Friday posts. If the average parent or guardian took the praise on the front cover at face value, they might have bought this book for a younger child who might not be ready for such intense scenes. I would be okay with telling a parent of a 10 year old to let them read this book. On the flip side, I would also have to provide a strong word of caution to the caretaker of a 5-7 year old reader.
Another thing that makes this book NOT all-ages is the techno-jargon. Lunella is one smart kid and she's a lot like Young Sheldon. She might know how to use enriched uranium but she shouldn't be allow to buy enriched uranium. (Maybe when she's 10...)
Having technical terms and advanced concepts isn't a bad thing in kids books. But if you want the young comic reader to fully enjoy the book, having an adult help with big words and complex thinking isn't a bad idea. Anytime you can get a parent and child reading together, it's a good thing and this is a series that really needs a reading partner if read by a child ages 9 or younger.
Where to Now?
Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur are still going strong as a monthly series by Marvel Comics. Original series writer Amy Reeder has moved on, though Natacha Bustos currently remains as head artist. Having not read past issue #6, I can't rate those issues. But this first volume was a pleasant burst of old school characters with new dynamic roles. In an era where Marvel's comics have become almost an afterthought to the live action films that they were based upon, this series gives me hope that the House of Ideas has yet to run out of them.
Hopefully that means that this new dynamic duo is here to stay. So if Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur is just a little too old for the young comic collector in your life- don't worry! They'll grow into it!
Worth Consuming!
Rating: 8 out of 10 stars.
Friday, November 17, 2017
The Not-So Secret Society: The Tale of the Gummy (Family Comic Friday)
It's time for another edition of Family Comic Friday. The book I have selected this week is called The Not-So Secret Society. The book is actually classified as a Halloween book on Amazon. When I first learned of this 2017 graphic novel from Kaboom!, I didn't even realize that it was a Halloween book.
I knew of this book as it was a selection of potential all-ages best of 2017 picks by Goodreads. So, when I found this at my local library, I was excited to read it because of that honor and didn't really know of the book's holiday implications. So please forgive me for not having a timely selection this week.
So what is the book about?
A group of middle school misfits called the Not-So Secret Society love science. But they're constantly overlooked by another group of science loving students that seem to make magic with their science projects. Tired of being upstaged, one of the members of the Not-So Secret Society challenges their rivals to build the greatest science fair experiment of all-time. The only problem- they've only got the weekend to do it and it just happens to be the same weekend that Halloween falls on.
Working with all their might, the students create a machine that can potentially bring any piece of candy to life! After some trial and error, the group finally manage to get a gummy bear candy to come alive. Only, this confection has a sweet tooth and everytime it eats sugar, the gummy doubles in size. With it being Halloween and candy everywhere, how can the members of the No-So Secret Society stop their mad science experiment without destroying the whole city block?
I actually enjoyed this book. It had heart, personality, and was pretty funny. Plus, I had fun reading it. The book started off very different than I expected however.
In the beginning, the Not-So Secret Society are in a subway terminal attempting to open some magical portal to another dimension. And they actually succeed. However, the book's authors Matthew and Arlene Daley never return to this plot line! I was convinced that somehow the kids had goofed in not securing the doorway and some creature got out. But that wasn't to be. Amazon seems to indicate that the Tale of the Gummy is the first in a series. So maybe they'll return to this plot point in the future?
There's a ton of extras at the end of this graphic novel. The Daley's, along with co-creators Trevor and Ellen Crafts are educators and they include several activities designed to make learning fun. Plus there's over 25 mini comic one-pagers that expand the personalities of the No-So Secret Society. The last story is actually a prequel to the beginning of The Tale of the Gummy. While only gag is by series artist Wook Jin Clark (Regular Show), I'm not sure why these adventures weren't placed at the beginning of the book. They really add a depth to the characters that is lacking in the first 30-pages of the book.
The No-So Secret Society have potential to be a great series for readers of all ages. But you, the readers are going to have to go out there and show your support if there's to be a volume 2. Yes, Halloween is the time of year this book is set, but The Tale of the Gummy can be enjoyed 365 days of the year! That's right, I'm saying it- this would make a great holiday gift!
Along with being available in paperback in bookstores everywhere, the NS3 can be found digitally on ComiXology and Kindle.
And that will do it for this week's Family Comic Friday. Next week, I turn big 4-0 and I count down my top 10 all-ages books and series of all-time. Until then, read on!
Worth Consuming!
Rating: 9 out of 10 stars.
Friday, September 29, 2017
A Madman Looks at the CBLDF and Banned Book Week... (A Family Comic Friday Extra)
Hello Dear Readers-
I've you've been following my blog, you will know that Banned Book Week is usually a very big deal to me. It still is, but this year was one of those times when life just got in the way. I've been super busy gearing up for the first week of classes next week and my blood sugars got out of whack after a nasty stomach bug. But writing unfortunately was the furthest thing from my mind.
I would have to say that reading as a close third- after eating. So I don't have a Family Comic Friday selection this week. But since I am feeling up to it, I decided to write an opinion piece on kids and banned books.
The following titles have something in common:
Weird Science, Huckleberry Finn, Bone, Dragon Ball, Amazing Spider-Man, Wolverine, and To Kill A Mockingbird.
Wanna guess what that common denominator is? If you guessed that all of those books have been challenged in either a school board or court room setting in hopes of being banned from libraries nationwide- then make a star out of gold tin foil and give it to yourself. You are right!
Banning materials doesn't just have to be of books. It can be TV and movies, clothing, even toys and games. But when it comes to those items, it's a little harder to fight against their banning because those are items that can become a legitimate distraction at school.
Take the fidget spinner for instance. Does it help children with learning and attention deficits be able to focus better in class? Absolutely, However, when every kid in school has one because it has become the latest fad for all the students to have it; then becomes an item that distracts everyone. At that point, then some parent or teacher gets mad and decides that the item needs to been removed from school premises for the sake of learning.
I have a friend who is in his 30s and works full-time and is a stand up guy. But last year, he was banned from his child's school because he wore a Darth Vader t-shirt when picking his kids up. Vader happened to be welding his light saber, a weapon, and thus under the school's weapon policy, was considered a potential threat to the school. My God, if that's the case, I'd be on death row! Because I have picked my kid sister up from school with Princess Leia holding a blaster in her hands.
The argument about whether my friend's shirt was going promote someone to go on a rampage is clearly not as dangerous as if my friend actually brought a working light saber to the school. It's also a lot easier to ban clothing than it is a book. But people still try.
Here's the how and why:
1. So the school makes a ruling that weapons of any kind cannot be on school property. Whether this be real, toy, fake, or on clothing and other accessories.
2. Then someone gets the bright idea that books have weapons in them. Take the classic Civil War novel The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane. Why, that book is about a war. Wars have guns. People die in wars from guns. Thus, the Red Badge of Courage must be banned from school because it may influence little Timmy to reenact the battle of Gettysburg at recess one day.
Maybe this example is too extreme. So let's look at one that is hitting very close to home for many parents and students right now- racism. I think we can all agree that the N-word is a word that shouldn't be used- especially to describe someone. Well, I know this might shock you but some of the greatest works in American literature use the N-word. One of those books is my favorite book of all-time is To Kill A Mockingbird.
TKAM was written by a white Southern woman named Harper Lee. But when she used the word in her book it wasn't to glorify it. Instead, it was to illustrated the harsh way blacks were treated in the pre-Civil Rights era. Lee herself was a member of the PRO civil rights movement and very vocal against the use of prejudicial treatment against of those of color. Yet every year, as sure as corn grows tall in the field, at least one school board in the US must hold a hearing in which someone challenges the right for Lee's book to be available in school libraries.
The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund is a charity very near and dear to my heart. Even though the charity was formed to help provide legal representation for comic book creators and sellers who find themselves in hot water for selling 'offensive material', the CBLDF has fought against censorship of books in school and public libraries nationwide. They also bring awareness of oppression to creators in foreign lands such as Iraq and Singapore who have been imprisoned because their comics challenged the rule of regime-like leadership. The CBLDF supports the First Amendment and the right of freedom of speech. The CBLDF also supports the right to read and own such speech and they will put up a legal fight when those freedom's are challenged.
Before I close, I want to make something clear- what is the difference between censorship and advisement? When I write reviews on my blog Madman With a Book for my weekly Family Comic Friday post, I give said work a grade based on 1-10 stars. I also tell parents that a book may have foul language, nudity, violence, or scary imagery. But I do not let those elements affect my grade for the book. I grade a book on quality of artwork, story structure, cohesion in the plot, and other elements of good storytelling. So if I grade a book 7 out of 10 stars and also say it's scary and has swears, the grade isn't due to that but because I found a number of flaws in the book's readability.
The purpose of my Family Comic Friday posts are to help parents, guardians and adults looking to introduce children to comics and graphic novels. There's a lot of stuff starring Wolverine that is for kids and even more that isn't. It is up to the parent to decide what to buy or not buy for their child.
The CBLDF believes that it is the individual's right to determine what to read and not read. I feel the same way. But as an educator, I also understand that some adults are clueless as to what is age appropriate and need guidance sometimes. Heck, even librarians need help too- Watchmen should never be put in the kids graphic novel section- no matter hard hard you try to draw pants on all the images of Dr. Manhattan. Which a novice librarian's helper actually offered to do when I pointed out that it had been miscategorized.
For more information about the CBLDF and Banned Books Week, check out their web page here.
I've you've been following my blog, you will know that Banned Book Week is usually a very big deal to me. It still is, but this year was one of those times when life just got in the way. I've been super busy gearing up for the first week of classes next week and my blood sugars got out of whack after a nasty stomach bug. But writing unfortunately was the furthest thing from my mind.
I would have to say that reading as a close third- after eating. So I don't have a Family Comic Friday selection this week. But since I am feeling up to it, I decided to write an opinion piece on kids and banned books.
The following titles have something in common:
Weird Science, Huckleberry Finn, Bone, Dragon Ball, Amazing Spider-Man, Wolverine, and To Kill A Mockingbird.
Wanna guess what that common denominator is? If you guessed that all of those books have been challenged in either a school board or court room setting in hopes of being banned from libraries nationwide- then make a star out of gold tin foil and give it to yourself. You are right!
Banning materials doesn't just have to be of books. It can be TV and movies, clothing, even toys and games. But when it comes to those items, it's a little harder to fight against their banning because those are items that can become a legitimate distraction at school.
Take the fidget spinner for instance. Does it help children with learning and attention deficits be able to focus better in class? Absolutely, However, when every kid in school has one because it has become the latest fad for all the students to have it; then becomes an item that distracts everyone. At that point, then some parent or teacher gets mad and decides that the item needs to been removed from school premises for the sake of learning.
I have a friend who is in his 30s and works full-time and is a stand up guy. But last year, he was banned from his child's school because he wore a Darth Vader t-shirt when picking his kids up. Vader happened to be welding his light saber, a weapon, and thus under the school's weapon policy, was considered a potential threat to the school. My God, if that's the case, I'd be on death row! Because I have picked my kid sister up from school with Princess Leia holding a blaster in her hands.
The argument about whether my friend's shirt was going promote someone to go on a rampage is clearly not as dangerous as if my friend actually brought a working light saber to the school. It's also a lot easier to ban clothing than it is a book. But people still try.
Here's the how and why:
1. So the school makes a ruling that weapons of any kind cannot be on school property. Whether this be real, toy, fake, or on clothing and other accessories.
2. Then someone gets the bright idea that books have weapons in them. Take the classic Civil War novel The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane. Why, that book is about a war. Wars have guns. People die in wars from guns. Thus, the Red Badge of Courage must be banned from school because it may influence little Timmy to reenact the battle of Gettysburg at recess one day.
Maybe this example is too extreme. So let's look at one that is hitting very close to home for many parents and students right now- racism. I think we can all agree that the N-word is a word that shouldn't be used- especially to describe someone. Well, I know this might shock you but some of the greatest works in American literature use the N-word. One of those books is my favorite book of all-time is To Kill A Mockingbird.
TKAM was written by a white Southern woman named Harper Lee. But when she used the word in her book it wasn't to glorify it. Instead, it was to illustrated the harsh way blacks were treated in the pre-Civil Rights era. Lee herself was a member of the PRO civil rights movement and very vocal against the use of prejudicial treatment against of those of color. Yet every year, as sure as corn grows tall in the field, at least one school board in the US must hold a hearing in which someone challenges the right for Lee's book to be available in school libraries.
The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund is a charity very near and dear to my heart. Even though the charity was formed to help provide legal representation for comic book creators and sellers who find themselves in hot water for selling 'offensive material', the CBLDF has fought against censorship of books in school and public libraries nationwide. They also bring awareness of oppression to creators in foreign lands such as Iraq and Singapore who have been imprisoned because their comics challenged the rule of regime-like leadership. The CBLDF supports the First Amendment and the right of freedom of speech. The CBLDF also supports the right to read and own such speech and they will put up a legal fight when those freedom's are challenged.
Before I close, I want to make something clear- what is the difference between censorship and advisement? When I write reviews on my blog Madman With a Book for my weekly Family Comic Friday post, I give said work a grade based on 1-10 stars. I also tell parents that a book may have foul language, nudity, violence, or scary imagery. But I do not let those elements affect my grade for the book. I grade a book on quality of artwork, story structure, cohesion in the plot, and other elements of good storytelling. So if I grade a book 7 out of 10 stars and also say it's scary and has swears, the grade isn't due to that but because I found a number of flaws in the book's readability.
The purpose of my Family Comic Friday posts are to help parents, guardians and adults looking to introduce children to comics and graphic novels. There's a lot of stuff starring Wolverine that is for kids and even more that isn't. It is up to the parent to decide what to buy or not buy for their child.
The CBLDF believes that it is the individual's right to determine what to read and not read. I feel the same way. But as an educator, I also understand that some adults are clueless as to what is age appropriate and need guidance sometimes. Heck, even librarians need help too- Watchmen should never be put in the kids graphic novel section- no matter hard hard you try to draw pants on all the images of Dr. Manhattan. Which a novice librarian's helper actually offered to do when I pointed out that it had been miscategorized.
For more information about the CBLDF and Banned Books Week, check out their web page here.
Friday, September 15, 2017
Cancelled- Family Comic Friday
Don't worry- it's not permanent.
I'm subbing for another Chef this week and didn't have time to devote to a Family Comic Friday this week. I will also be filling in next Friday as well. So come back September 29th for our next edition.
Until then, keep checking in as I'll have other reviews of films, TV, and books set to post in the coming days.
Have a Great Weekend!
Friday, January 27, 2017
Young Justice, Volume 1 (Family Comic Friday)
Last November, it was announced that acclaimed Cartoon Network series Young Justice would finally be getting a third season after a massive write-in campaign on Facebook. It has been 3 years since the show went off the air abruptly. Lots of fans were highly disappointed in the cancellation I was one of those fans. I was also one of those fans who demanded more of that awesome series.
I'm not really sure why Cartoon Network cancelled the show. It had strong ratings, critics loved it, and DVD sales of seasons 1 and 2 were very strong. One thing that the show didn't have much of a following in was readership of the comic book tie-in.
Recently, I found a trade paper back edition of the first few issues of the series. I was totally blown away by it. Briefly, the book gives a kind of overhead that's just like the series. How the team of Robin, Aqualad, and Kid Flash got together with the niece of the Martian Manhunter and a clone of Superman from Cadmus, a research facility of questionable means is taken straight from Cartoon Network.
After the intros, the book follows the plot of the series but ventures off unto it's own after that. The Young Justice team are used as a covert strike force by the Justice League. Their main enemy are the secret villains of the League of Shadows. Plus, Superboy seeks both his place in this world and Superman's acceptance. It's great stuff full of action, twists, and turns.
Anybody wanna guess who the writing talents are behind this amazing series based on the equally amazing series of the same name? Why it's Art Baltazar and Franco of Tiny Titans fame. The artwork is just as breathtaking. The combined efforts of Christopher Jones (Batman '66) and Mike Norton (Hack/Slash) looks so much like the characters of the series. Overall, this was the right group to chronicle the paper adventures of Young Justice.
This series has been out of circulation since 2013. So why am I reviewing their efforts now? Well, with Young Justice 3 just in the development stage, the hype for the comics is very low. But that's not going to be for long. Copies of this book can be found in bargain bins for a dollar or less. But, that's not the case on Amazon. 3 of the 4 trades that collect this series are being listed for prices of anywhere $20-$100+!
I'm telling you folks, this series is going to get hot quick! When your children fall in love with the new series and you can't find these comics, don't come crying to me! You've been warned!
Young Justice is not an all-ages book but it is family friendly. Readers aged 10- up will delight in these adventures. You just have to find them and for a collector like me, that's half of the fun!
Worth Consuming
Rating: 10 out of 10 stars.
I'm not really sure why Cartoon Network cancelled the show. It had strong ratings, critics loved it, and DVD sales of seasons 1 and 2 were very strong. One thing that the show didn't have much of a following in was readership of the comic book tie-in.
Recently, I found a trade paper back edition of the first few issues of the series. I was totally blown away by it. Briefly, the book gives a kind of overhead that's just like the series. How the team of Robin, Aqualad, and Kid Flash got together with the niece of the Martian Manhunter and a clone of Superman from Cadmus, a research facility of questionable means is taken straight from Cartoon Network.
After the intros, the book follows the plot of the series but ventures off unto it's own after that. The Young Justice team are used as a covert strike force by the Justice League. Their main enemy are the secret villains of the League of Shadows. Plus, Superboy seeks both his place in this world and Superman's acceptance. It's great stuff full of action, twists, and turns.
Anybody wanna guess who the writing talents are behind this amazing series based on the equally amazing series of the same name? Why it's Art Baltazar and Franco of Tiny Titans fame. The artwork is just as breathtaking. The combined efforts of Christopher Jones (Batman '66) and Mike Norton (Hack/Slash) looks so much like the characters of the series. Overall, this was the right group to chronicle the paper adventures of Young Justice.
This series has been out of circulation since 2013. So why am I reviewing their efforts now? Well, with Young Justice 3 just in the development stage, the hype for the comics is very low. But that's not going to be for long. Copies of this book can be found in bargain bins for a dollar or less. But, that's not the case on Amazon. 3 of the 4 trades that collect this series are being listed for prices of anywhere $20-$100+!
I'm telling you folks, this series is going to get hot quick! When your children fall in love with the new series and you can't find these comics, don't come crying to me! You've been warned!
Young Justice is not an all-ages book but it is family friendly. Readers aged 10- up will delight in these adventures. You just have to find them and for a collector like me, that's half of the fun!
Worth Consuming
Rating: 10 out of 10 stars.
Friday, December 30, 2016
Family Comic Friday: Under Construction
Family Comic Friday will be published tomorrow. I'm working on my end of year review and I am not quite done.
But tomorrow look forward to my Top 5 comic picks, plus my choice for best comic based TV show, cartoon, and movie of 2016!
See you then....
But tomorrow look forward to my Top 5 comic picks, plus my choice for best comic based TV show, cartoon, and movie of 2016!
See you then....
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








