Walt Disney's Uncle Scrooge and Donald Duck: 'Return to Plain Awful'- The Don Rosa Library, Vol. 2

Don Rosa gets a lot of hate from Duck fans. But no matter how much a collector might despise his work, the harshest critic of Don Rosa is Rosa himself. And I just don't know why. 

Rosa is a disciple of the greatest Duck creator of them all, 'the good Duck artist' Carl Barks. And sure, you never want to exceed your hero. But while Don Rosa is no Carl Barks, I think it should be said that Carl Barks is no Don Rosa either!

The artist originally born as Keno Rosa has a style in the vein of Harvey Kurtzman with tiny little inclusions of hidden images and inside jokes- usually in the background. I absolutely love that. Each Duck story of Rosa's that I read, I feel like a detective trying to find all the Easter eggs hidden in every panel. Thank goodness Rosa wrote his own commentary situated at the end of this volume as sometimes, no matter how hard I try, I just can't find where he hid the word 'D.U.C.K.' in the art of the first page. (Note: you should also be on the lookout for hidden Mickey's and portraits of Barks throughout...)

In this volume we get to enjoy a number of adventures throughout Duckburg and the furthest reaches of the globe. The cover story sees Uncle Scrooge tagging along with his nephews to Plain Awful in hopes of securing the market on square chicken eggs. But he'll have to beat rival Glomgold Flintheart to Peru first! 

My favorite story has Scrooge declaring his money bin a sovereign nation. The headaches that come about with tariffs, passports and an invading army of Beagle Boys makes this story so relevant to today's headlines that you would swear that this story wasn't written over 35 years ago.

There's a couple of real hidden gems that I don't feel like Rosa gives himself enough credit for. First is a storyboard for a never published promotional comic highlighting Donald and his nephews' inaugural trip to Disney MGM Studios. As it's Rosa's only story to have Donald and Mickey interacting in the same universe, it's not to be missed! Then there's Rosa's only foray into the DuckTales realm. He only penned it and it's less than 8 pages, but this prehistoric time travel romp with Magica De Spell was so fun!

I needed this book as a bit of retail therapy and a pick-me-up after a very difficult weekend. I had a ball with this book. I laughed, I examined and I appreciated the artwork and I distressed. I just wish Don Rosa knew how much somebody appreciated his body of work. He's ton better than he gives himself credit for!

Worth Consuming!

Rating: 9 out of 10 stars.

Uncle Scrooge and the Infinity Dime #1 (Family Comic Friday)

If Don Rosa's The Old Castle's Other Secret is the quintessential ending to the story of Scrooge McDuck, then this tale is the epilogue!

Jason Aaron pens a story that asks what if on that fateful snowy Christmas on Bear Mountain, Donald and his nephews never showed up? Scrooge would still be motivated to discover all those hidden treasures. However, without the bonds of family to experience those adventures with, McDuck would still be wanting more. Thus, when he uncovers an enchanted mirror that can breach the barrier between worlds, that world's Worlds Richest Duck will seek to become the richest duck of all the worlds!

I'm actually surprised that there hasn't been such a story before this. Multiverse type stories are extremely popular right now and it seems like every franchise from Rick and Morty to Scooby-Doo has done such a story in one medium or another. 

A bevy of artists contributed beautiful work on this book which might seem a little expensive with a $7.99 price. However it's got a ton of extras including the story that inspired this comic, Christmas on Bear Mountain, which introduced readers to Uncle Scrooge way back in 1947. That debut story is remastered to crystal clear perfection and worth the extra cost.

Uncle Scrooge and the Infinity Dime is the first Disney Ducks comic book ever from Marvel. The House of Ideas had tested a Disney comic in the early 90s, featuring popular franchises like the Little Mermaid, but they were victims of the comic book bubble. I've had this book on my wish list ever since I learned about its existence back in March. I would have gotten it the day it dropped in stores if I wasn't so gosh darn tired from driving all the day prior back from vacation. So I got it the next day after a big rest. But I didn't have to worry about it selling out because I made sure to order a copy from my favorite comic book store early!

Speaking of orders, thanks to the special material at the end of this book, I've got not one but 2 more Disney one-shots by Marvel to look forward to in the next couple of months. Donald Duck is being given the What If... treatment in 2 new specials that ask what would happen if Scrooge's nephew was subject to the Weapon X program and then found the hammer of Thor. With an Aliens What If... miniseries just wrapping up and these Disney issues forthcoming, I'm hoping that Star Wars is next to go under the watchful eye of the Watcher.

I'm not sure if Jason Aaron is ready to be listed with the likes of Rosa, Carl Barks and William Van Horn. But he's got my blessing to write more stories starring Scrooge and his nephews. Aaron crafted a perfect all-ages adventure that includes appearances by inventor Gyro Gearloose and those dastardly Beagle Boys. (Be sure to look out for a cameo made by the adult version of Simba from The Lion King!) I only wish that with the Christmas time book-ending of this story, and the inclusion of Scrooge's holiday set debut, that this book had come out in December. You're welcome to wait and read this book closer to Christmas. But where's the fun in that?

Oh... Can someone please tell me what happened to Donald and his nephews that kept them from visiting McDuck that Christmas on that alternate Earth? That's a mystery I'd like solved! Maybe Jason Aaron can explain that in a follow up to this funtastic multiverse romp!

Worth Consuming!

Rating: 10 out of 10 stars.

Uncle Scrooge and the Infinity Dime debuted in print and digital formats on June 19th, 2024.

Walt Disney's Uncle Scrooge "The Seven Cities of Gold": The Complete Carl Barks Disney Library Vol. 14

According to the expert commentary at the end of this book, the time period covered here was a very difficult time creatively for creator Carl Barks. For those of you wondering, we're talking 1955-1960. Apparently, Barks and the editors at Western Publishing butted heads over the contents of several stories. All of a sudden, the editorial staff began nitpicking over every little thing and especially took issue with anything that they deemed to be too violent.

The commentators don't seem to know why the sudden change. How good a comic book historian can these experts be if they can't make the connection that Western Publishing was freaking out over concerns brought about by the Comics Scare of the 1950s and the newly established Comics Code?!

True, I purchase and read the volumes of the Carl Barks collection out of order because I shop for the books based on current affordability and not sequence. Maybe in a previous or later volume, the commentaries will dive into the Comics Code. I just think if you're going to question why about something, you really either need to figure out the reasoning or don't call yourself the authority on something. It just makes for poor research. But that's probably just the history major in me coming out.

Within this difficult time, it's said that Barks' productivity waned and his creativity stagnated. I just don't see evidence of that in this book. In fact, for someone who grew up on DuckTales, this volume seems to align with that classic 80s toon the most out of the several volumes in this set I now own!

Several amazing adventures starring Uncle Scrooge and his nephews Donald, Huey, Dewey and Louie take the ducks across the globe including an epic trek all over planet Earth in search of the fabled Philosopher's Stone. Then there's the sci-fi adventure The Mysterious Stone Ray starring those dastardly Beagle Boys. My favorite was The Golden Fleecing which I believe was adapted for the Disney cartoon series! Plus the origins of Scrooge's steamboat days are explored in action packed story titled The Great Steamboat Race. 

When I reviewed Don Rosa's The Complete Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck, I commented how much I disliked the talent making Scrooge so ornery. Yet, this volume here confirms that Carl Barks was behind the anger because in reality, he was a very disgruntled man. I'd really like to read a biography about Barks. Though I'm not all that sure if such a thing exists. And if it does, I surely hope it's not written by the 'expert' who neglected to connect the damage Dr. Wertham did to the comic book industry in the 1950s to all the in-fighting between Carl Barks and his editors. For if it is, I might have to take a pass.

Worth Consuming!

Rating: 8 out of 10 stars.

The Complete Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck, Vol. 2

As nearly flawless as Don Rosa's Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck was, the story was far from over. After the 12-part story concluded, both fans and Rosa himself wanted more. So, the Kentucky cartoonist returned to McDuck's scrap book to uncover more episodes in the life of the World's Richest Duck. Featuring the return of Glittering Goldie, Teddy Roosevelt and those dastardly Beagle Boys, these stories are like the frame around the Mona Lisa. As much as it  encapsulates the masterpiece, it's not what draws in millions of visitors to the Louvre. But it doesn't mean that their existence isn't important to putting together a complete portrait!

Concluding this volume is 'The Old Castle's Other Secret or A Letter From Home'. It was Rosa's final published Duck story.  A sequel to an earlier work of his called 'The Crown of the Crusader Kings', this story is also a sequel to Carl Barks' 'Secret of the Old Castle'. That classic was the first Duck story a very young Don Rosa ever read, inspiring him to become a comic book creator, it brings the story of Scrooge McDuck full circle in more ways than one. Sadly, poor vision due to a detached retina resulted in Rosa retiring actively from comics. Because I want to know more of what happened after this story and I kinda want to read what Rosa hints in the introduction as what he envisions the final McDuck story to ever be. I have a feeling it finally brings Scrooge and Goldie together. I also think that if that story ever came to pass, I'd weep uncontrollably as my favorite Disney character's story officially came to an end. 

This second volume includes a couple of stories published before Rosa undertook the herculean effort of crafting the original Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck story. Fantagraphics has published all of Rosa's Duck works in a 10 volume set. While I have a feeling I can skip the 2 volumes that reprint his magnum opus, I don't think I can get around not getting the other 8 volumes just because I have this deluxe edition book. Maybe I can get trade credit for this later on...

A great read of which I can't wait to read again when I get those Rosa books in the future. And after that, I just might read Rosa's swan song a few more times after that!

Worth Consuming!

Rating: 10 out of 10 stars.

The Complete Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck, Vol. 1 (2024 Comic Book & Graphic Novel Reading Challenge)

A chance encounter with a Gladstone comic book in 1986 changed the life of cartoonist Don Rosa forever. 

Don Rosa grew up showing great artistic talent. Rosa went through grade school and high school submitting strips for various educational and local publications. Despite working towards a degree in civil engineering at the University of Kentucky, Rosa continued to fine tune his craft submitting art for a pair of fanzines devoted to Carl Barks and the Disney ducks as well as the college paper, The Kentucky Kernel where Rosa contributed a strip devoted to political satire. Despite not considering himself a political cartoonist, Rosa won an award in 1969 for his work and was later named one of the top college artists in the nation by The Journal of Higher Education.

After graduating, Don Rosa went to work at his family's construction business which was started in 1900 by his grandfather, an Italian immigrant. Rosa was resided to work primarily in the family business while moonlighting part time as a cartoonist with a weekly strip called The  Adventures of Captain Kentucky that appeared in The Louisville Times. However, the endeavor was far from satisfying for Rosa and in 1982, the cartoonist retired outright.

It appeared that fate had destined for Don Rosa to work the rest of his days selling the Italian tile and marble products that his family had become legendary for. Then one day fate changed Rosa's career path once again. Upon stumbling upon a Disney comic published by Gladstone, Rosa learned that Disney was once again publishing books based on their properties in the United States and were in need of American writers and artists to fill those pages. Rosa grew up a fan of Carl Barks' Donald Duck and Uncle Scrooge adventures and he felt destined to be the one to usher in the next generation of Duck tales. Rosa contacted editor Byron Erickson who agreed to a tryout. The result was a globetrotting search for treasure between Scrooge McDuck and the dastardly Flintheart Glomgold in 'The Son of the Sun.' In 1987, Rosa's Disney debut was nominated for a Harvey Award for Best Story of the Year.

After a few more stories, Rosa prayed ways with Disney as the company had a policy that would not return artwork back to the artist. However, Rosa's affiliation with the residents of Duckburg was far from over. The hit syndicated cartoon DuckTales brought forth a resurgence in both the original works of Barks, along with Rosa's newer adventures. After learning about how popular his Disney stories had become in Europe, Rosa freelanced for the Denmark based Gutenberghus, now know as Egmont. 

In 1990-91, word started to spread that Disney was wanting to issue a miniseries on the long and stories life of Scrooge McDuck. Rosa encouraged Egmont to select one of their employees for the task as the international publisher had an impressive team of artists and writers that could execute the job successfully. Egmont's editors agreed and recommended Rosa for the job. Beginning in 1991, Rosa crafted The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck. 

The 12-chapter miniseries chronicled Scrooge's Scottish childhood fraught with poverty and lessons in hard work through his numerous failures in business until Scrooge finally struck gold literally in the Yukon Gold Rush of the late 1890s. The story comes to a close right where Carl Barks introduced the world to Scrooge McDuck in the 1947 story 'Christmas on Bear Mountain.' Having become the richest person in the world, Scrooge lives alone as miser until he decides to test his remaining relatives, nephew Donald Duck and his grand-nephews Huey Dewey and Louie, in order to see if they are worthy of inheriting his countless riches.

Building upon the foundation Carl Barks laid decades earlier, The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck answers questions long posed by Disney comic readers. How did the Beagle Boys come to be a perennial thorn in the side of Uncle Scrooge? Why does Flintheart hate McDuck so much? Why is that first dime so important to Scrooge? Plus, the entire family tree of Clan McDuck is explained, giving away many of the secrets of the old family castle as well as finally understanding where Granny, lucky duck Gladstone Gander and other residents of Duckburg relate to Scrooge McDuck and his kin.

In 1995, The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck won the Eisner Award for Best Serialized Story from appearing in issues of Anders And & Co. from 1992-1994. American audiences would be introduced to the story in the pages of Uncle Scrooge #285-296 beginning in late 1994. 

Over the following years, Rosa would craft several 'fill-in' stories that added to the mystique of Scrooge McDuck's life but do not have to be ready in any order in relation to the 12-part miniseries. An emergency surgery as the result of a detached retina would be the final straw in a career marred by low pay, creative differences and royalties in regards to intellectual property rights leading Rosa to ultimately retire from comics in 2008. He still continues to tour the convention circuit and conducts semi-annual signing tours in Europe where he enjoys superstar status.

Completing this review completes Task #6 (Best Single Issue or Serialized Story to Win an Eisner Award) of the 2024 Comic Book and Graphic Novel Reading Challenge.

Worth Consuming!

Rating: 9 out of 10 stars.

Disney Uncle Scrooge & Donald Duck in Les Miserables and War and Peace (Family Comic Friday)

Topolino is Italian for 'little mouse'. It's also the name of Italy's long running Disney comic book that features original material starring your favorite House of Mouse characters including Goofy, the Phantom Blot and Pluto. In this volume devoted to Disney-fied 19th century European classical works, the stars are all from your favorite family of ducks! Uncle Scrooge, Donald, Daisy, nephews Huey, Dewey and Louie and many more appear in these comical adaptations of Les Miserables and Crime and Punishment. This being an Uncle Scrooge heavy work, you can rest assured that his biggest foes, the Beagle Boys are on hand to create some mischief as well!

Material from the pages of Topolino have been covered by me previously on several reviews of American Disney works. I usually state that poor translations from the original Italian text into English are the main problems with those works. Phrases would seem stilted or out of place. That's just not the case here.The previous works I reviewed were published by IDW Publishing. Here, Fantagraphics, who've been doing an amazing job releasing the complete works of Carl Barks and Don Rosa, are the publishers and their translations have been phenomenal.

Both original novels deal with some very mature and violent subject matter. Les Miserables sees a single mother forced to sell her body to pay for her daughters room and board as well as the cold blooded murder of a young street urchin. While the main plot of Inspector Javert seeks to apprehend the fugitive Jean Valjean is still covered in this comic adaptation, the violent uprising in the streets of Paris has been replaced with a farcical search for the missing crown jewels of Charlemagne. Don't worry, there's still plenty of adventures to be had in the sewers under those Parisian streets.

As for War and Peace, I've never read the book nor seen an version of it in film. (With Les Mis, my wife and I have seen the musical about a half dozen times.) So I don't really have a good idea of how much material was replaced with more family friendly situations. However I cannot find evidence of the main character of the original Leo Tolstoy work trying to hide his horde of gold by melting them down into cannonballs and then having to retrieve the spent projectiles from the battle field after they are accidentally used during the Napoleonic Wars.

Both stories were written and illustrated by Giovan Battista Carpi. He's considered to be the Italian Carl Barks. The quality of these two parodies proves that belief. The plots are brilliant mixes of the original source material and the world of adventure created by those American masters whose stories first appeared in the pages of Dell and Whitman Disney comics decades ago.

In no way should this collection be used as a replacement for reading the originals. However both works are nearly a thousand pages each. Plus a lot of the terms and sentence structure are over 125 years old. Younger audiences might have difficulty relating. Unlike Classics Illustrated and Pocket Classics, these Disney adaptations should not even be used as study aids. But this book could very well be the link to interest young readers to want to read more about both the authors and their masterpieces. Sometimes humor is needed to peak interest into serious issues and this pair of parodies are hysterical. 

Perfect for all ages; especially fans of either version of DuckTales!

Worth Consuming!

Rating: 9 out of 10 stars.

Mickey's Craziest Adventures

The unique premise of this 2017 offering from IDW Publishing is that a pair of cartoonists discovered a lost Disney Comic at a flea market. When originally published in 1965, the comic was deemed too wild for readers and lost for decades in the Disney Archives. Here Mickey and Donald team-up to retrieve Uncle Scrooge's money which has been stolen by arch fiends Peg-Leg Pete and the Beagle Boys!

I really enjoyed this unique graphic novel. The story is 'recreated' from old and damaged comics. It's also incomplete meaning that there's jumps in time throughout the tale. Plus the pages have scenes torn out or littered with moisture damage and mold. There's even a coffee ring stain on one page!

Created by French cartoonists Lewis Trondheim and Nicolas Keramidas, I read this 50-page over-sized graphic novel in one whirlwind sitting. It's filled with all of your favorite Disney characters including Donald's nephews, Pluto and Gyro Gearloose. 

Since IDW Publishing obtained the rights around 2015 to publish comics based on Disney's most popular properties, I've been a little critical. While I have enjoyed just about everything IDW has put out Disney, I have wondered why the publisher has only been releasing never-before-seen reprints from across the globe. My demands were finally answered in this publication. While Mickey's Craziest Adventures is by two French creators, and from a rumored 'lost' comic, this is an all-new story! 

I hope we'll see more of such a thing from IDW. I also hope that there will be even more crazy adventures of Mickey by Trondheim and Keramidas. This was so much fun to read. Classic-style Disney with just a slight 2010 edge to it! 

IDW- act quick and get Trondheim and Keramidas back to that flea market! I am sure there's more undiscovered Disney comics in need of finding!

Worth Consuming!

Rating: 10 out of 10 stars. 

Mickey and Donald Christmas Parade #4 (2018)

An adorable collection of stories starring Mickey, Donald and more of your favorite Disney characters. 

Highlights include:

• While doing some last minute Christmas shopping, Mickey finds a magic coat that starts spitting out tens and twenties.
• Donald challenges his nephews to the ultimate snow ball fight.
• It's Christmas Eve and the Beagle Boys escape from prison once again. Instead of downtown Duckburg, the crooks wind up in Wonderland!

I really, really enjoyed the Wonderland story. I just recently finished reading IDW's Disney's Christmas Classics which is comprised of dozens of rare holiday crossover stories involving Peter Pan, Snow White and many more favorites. Alice and her Wonderland cronies were not a part of that amazing series. So, this was a fun treat, especially as Alice is one of my two all-time favorite Disney films.

Once again all of the stories are taken from Disney comic mags from across the globe. The artwork is classic and very visually stunning. And I think that the translators of these stories from their original language into English are getting better. I saw one awkward misstep but overall, the language barrier and lost in translation factors in previous IDW Disney specials is getting few and far between.

One thing I noticed and if any of my readers can explain this curiosity, I would appreciate it. I've noticed that dogs are the dominant species in these stories. I am not talking Pluto, walking on all fours dogs. I mean Goofy on only two legs pups. I'm going to say that these characters are beagles as the all look like the Beagle Boys. With exception of main characters, like Uncle Scrooge or Daisy, all of the minor characters are dogs. Why is that?

A very fun Christmas special that was a trip back to the classic days of Disney. 

Worth Consuming!

Rating: 8 out of 10 stars.